This article is no longer actively maintained. While it remains accessible for reference, exercise caution as the information within may be outdated. Use it judiciously and consider verifying its content in light of the latest developments.
Answer by Hugh Falkner
Few intensively used industrial motors will go through their working life without needing some attention from a motor repairer. Having established that repair is preferable to complete replacement, how do you identify a quality repairer?
Hazardous area motors can only be repaired by companies with the correct accreditation, but for standard motors there is no general certification scheme to identify a quality repairer. In the absence of personal recommendations, the following questions should be asked:
- Qualifications and experience of their staff. Does it seem sufficient?
- Do they have a wide range of wire gauges? It should be adequate to avoid having to make inefficient substitutes.
- How often do they calibrate the burn out oven thermostat? If the temperature is not well controlled, then the laminations are more likely to be damaged while removing the wire.
- As far as is possible, does the workshop look reasonably clean and tidy? Quality repair is about attention to detail, and so a workmanlike environment really does matter.
- What are their procedures for inspecting a motor on arrival, and on departure?
- Do their main customers seem to be those that will value quality?
Some repairers will be accredited to a Quality Standard, but this will only warrant that they are following declared procedures. It will not be a guarantee that these are the optimal ones for motor repair.
For information on best practice repair of motors, the following guide is recommended: The effect of repair/rewinding on motor efficiency (EASA). This is available free for download at http://www.easa.com/MaintainingMotorEfficiency.
It shouldn’t be forgotten that the motor user also has a responsibility in ensuring a quality repair, as demanding a high speed repair, or the repair of a motor that should really be scrapped, will lead to an inevitable compromise in quality.
If you are wondering whether a motor should be replaced or repaired, see also our application note on Electric motor asset management.
Last update 2-Jul-2021